Resolving the Conflict Between My Religion and the Buddha’s Teachings

Introduction by Nancy Acord

The following reflection is from a Dhamma friend who was born into a Hindu family and has been meditating with me since 2007. She describes how she worked through a longstanding conflict between her religious beliefs and the Buddha’s teachings, allowing her to practice with greater clarity and ease.

A Dhamma friend’s reflection

I was born Hindu and come from a family that has practiced Hinduism for generations. This year, I finally resolved an inner conflict concerning my religious beliefs and the Buddha’s teachings—a conflict that had become an obstacle to my meditation practice.

The main difficulty concerned ātman, the self as understood in my Hindu tradition, and anattā, or not-self, in the Buddha’s teachings. I saw a difference between these teachings and wondered whether practicing Buddhist meditation conflicted with my religion. This uncertainty made me hesitate in my practice.

I have been meditating with Nancy since 2007, close to twenty years. Through this long experience, I have come to appreciate that the practical benefits of the Buddha’s teachings can reach people across religious boundaries. Insight and concentration meditation help me discover what causes suffering and how that suffering can be relieved. I can investigate these things directly in my own body and mind while continuing to identify as Hindu.

What changed was my understanding of the relationship between my religious identity and my meditation practice. I had felt that I needed to reconcile every difference before I could practice wholeheartedly. Now I can acknowledge those differences while remaining open to what practice reveals. Within my own life, my Hindu faith and the meditation I practice with Nancy can continue alongside each other. I no longer feel caught between them.

Now I am mostly happy and calm, and I deal more peacefully with whatever happens in my life. This is different from how I experienced life for more than fifty years. I experienced happiness, sadness, anger, fear, and many other emotions. Whenever difficulties arose, I prayed for better outcomes.

I now have a clearer way of understanding what happens in life through causes and conditions. I cannot make everything turn out as I wish, but I can pay attention to the conditions I help create through my thoughts, words, and actions. Each day, I try to cultivate wholesome conditions and calmly respond to whatever comes my way.

The uncertainty that once made me hesitate has eased. Finally, my mind is at ease when I practice meditation.

Supporting suttas

Background on not-self and intentional action mentioned in the reflection.

SN 22.59 · The Five (Brethren): the not-self characteristic
The five aggregates as not-self. Translated by Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu.

AN 6.63 · Penetrative: intention and action
Section 5, on intention and actions of body, speech, and mind. Translated by Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu.

Next
Next

Appreciative Joy: An Opportunity for Insight